Troy
Directed by Wolfgang Petersen
A big, handsome retelling of the Trojan War that removes the gods and loses much of Homer’s depth.
Read the reviewBased on Frank Miller’s graphic novel, 300 tells the story of Leonidas and his Spartans at Thermopylae in a heavily stylised world of slow-motion combat, golden skies and spraying blood. Gerard Butler gives a full-throated performance as the Spartan king, and the film’s look has been imitated endlessly since.
As history, it is almost entirely fantasy. The Persians are turned into monsters, Xerxes becomes a towering god-king, and the thousands of other Greek soldiers who fought at Thermopylae are all but written out. The real Spartans would also have been surprised to be cast as defenders of freedom, since their society depended on the enslaved helots.
Taken on its own terms, as a heroic legend told around a campfire, it is a lot of fun.
Watch it for the spectacle, then read Herodotus for the truth.
Every review reflects the personal perspective of the Hellenic Heritage Club.
Read next
Directed by Wolfgang Petersen
A big, handsome retelling of the Trojan War that removes the gods and loses much of Homer’s depth.
Read the reviewDirected by Oliver Stone
An ambitious but muddled portrait of Alexander, rescued in part by spectacular battle scenes.
Read the reviewDirected by Desmond Davis
A charming fantasy version of the Perseus myth, made unforgettable by Ray Harryhausen’s stop-motion monsters.
Read the review