Skip to content

ΚFilm review

Troy

A big, handsome retelling of the Trojan War that removes the gods and loses much of Homer’s depth.

Directed by Wolfgang PetersenWorth watching

Troy squeezes a ten-year war into what seems like a few weeks and removes the gods entirely, turning the story into a human drama of pride, love and politics. Brad Pitt makes a brooding, magnetic Achilles, and Eric Bana is excellent as a decent, dutiful Hector, whose duel with Achilles is the high point of the film.

Readers of the Iliad will notice many changes. Characters who survive in the myths die here, and the film is more interested in spectacle than in the moral depth of the poem. Peter O’Toole’s brief scene as Priam, begging for his son’s body, is the closest it comes to Homer’s power.

The 2007 director’s cut is longer, darker and generally considered the better version.

Our verdict

An enjoyable blockbuster that may send viewers back to the original.

Every review reflects the personal perspective of the Hellenic Heritage Club.

Read next

  • FilmMixed

    Alexander

    Directed by Oliver Stone

    2004

    An ambitious but muddled portrait of Alexander, rescued in part by spectacular battle scenes.

    Read the review
  • FilmWorth watching

    Clash of the Titans

    Directed by Desmond Davis

    1981

    A charming fantasy version of the Perseus myth, made unforgettable by Ray Harryhausen’s stop-motion monsters.

    Read the review
  • FilmWorth watching

    Agora

    Directed by Alejandro Amenábar

    2009

    A moving, underrated drama about the philosopher Hypatia and the twilight of learning in Roman Alexandria.

    Read the review
Made with Modulify